A Barbár - Legenda a szellemharcosról

Az akció annyira átláthatatlan, hogy nem látod, mi történik, és csak úgy tudod meg, ki ölt meg kit, hogy ki az, aki élve jön ki a harcból. A 300 című filmben is látható költői és áttekinthető csaták korában egy ilyen hátrány megbocsáthatatlan, főleg egy olyan filmben, amely elsősorban az akcióra épül. A történetmesélés és munka a karakterekkel pedig Marcus Nispel számára teljesen ismeretlen fogalom. Mit tud valójában ez az alkotó? Ebben az esetben csak érzelmileg lapos sötétségbe burkolni a filmvásznat. Egy borzalmas film, amely a legrosszabb videojáték-adaptációk intelligenciaszintjén álló forgatókönyvön alapul, és amelyet teljesen eltemetnek az utolsó cliffhanger jelenetek, amelyek Ed Wood filmes technikájára emlékeztetnek (hosszú felvételek egy lezúduló lavináról, Isten tudja honnan). Hosszas habozás után 1*-ra kell levinnem. Ez nem való a mozikba. (2007.06.17)

A bored Karl Urban in his least charismatic role to day, an interesting premise that is wasted, brutally heavy-handed fights (all of them in slow-motion!), awful-looking CGI blood in every other shot, a stupidly simple mythology and message, a plot that is not really worth talking about. In short, a brilliant example of a butchered high-budget and grandstanding project that has the soul of a hundred-year-old corpse. (2008.02.17)

The positives end with the subject matter, which is quite decent (but incidentally stolen from the literary classic J. F. Cooper). The rest is a mix of retarded cluelessness of both the screenwriter (half a page of the main axis, about 10 lines for the main character’s dialogue, and a handful of terrible dialogues) and the director, who should have it explained to him that there is no darkness like darkness and that the de-colored filter, together with the chaotic editing and the constantly thundering music are not particularly in fashion. Pathfinder lacks charisma (Karl Urban is bored instead of being a tough guy), insight (there really is a lot of marble here), and most of all balls. The opening credits and the atmospheric prologue, which is relatively well handled, are perhaps the most interesting parts of this whole charade. This is probably the worst high-budget blockbuster currently available. (2007.07.05)

Rough fantasy fairy tale that partially reminded me of Barbara Conan. It has about as much in common with the historical reality of the Vikings as I do as an atheist with the function of a Roman Catholic cardinal. Within the genre, it is clearly below average in terms of both screenplay and direction. The costumes are perhaps worth mentioning... Overall impression 25%. (2007.06.21)

Norwegians, like a bunch of hobnailed predators, hippie Indians, and Karl Urban, half-naked, rides under majestic mountain peaks. Only old Homolka with a two-handed ax, praising the panoramas, is missing. Nispel is a loser who can scare you in all manner of ways, especially through his complete amateurism. Unwatchable bullshit. (2009.06.17)